SLIP complexity


Brian Lloyd (mimsy!cvl!dolqci!irs3!wb6rqn!brian@rutgers.edu)
30 Mar 88 22:01:41 EST (Wed)


Rick, you are right, 95% of the time it is a waste to add error
correction to a SLIP link. On the other hand the checksum routines in
TCP and IP are not very robust. They work just fine in the presence of
single bit errors but will fall down in the presence of burst errors. I
am perfectly willing to allow TCP to handle the request for
retransmission of "lost" packets but I do not want to rely on the
checksum routines to ensure that the packets are good. Too much margin
for error.

At Sirius Systems we are adding an option that will allow you to turn on
one of three error handling modes: current SLIP (no error checking),
CRC-CCITT error checking where it discards bad frames, and lastly the
retransmission of bad frames.

I expect that most sites will run in the first mode and the rest will
run in the second mode. We may just ignore the third mode altogether,
especially in light of modems like the trailblazer (which we love too).

Brian Lloyd, President
Sirius Systems, Inc.
(301) 540-2066
{bellcore, syscad, cp1, irs3, n3dmc}!wb6rqn!brian
Share and enjoy!



This archive was generated by hypermail 2.0b3 on Thu Mar 09 2000 - 14:41:54 GMT